IT Brief US - Technology news for CIOs & IT decision-makers
United States
Insurance agents use AI daily despite compliance fears

Insurance agents use AI daily despite compliance fears

Wed, 18th Nov 2026 (Today)
Joseph Gabriel Lagonsin
JOSEPH GABRIEL LAGONSIN News Editor

CYPHER Learning has published research showing that only 33% of property and casualty insurance agents are very confident their use of artificial intelligence complies with organisational rules. It also found that 74% usually or always send AI-generated content to clients without editing it.

The survey covered 125 U.S. independent agents focused on property and casualty lines, including home, motor, liability and renters insurance, as part of a wider sample of 400 agents across insurance, finance and real estate.

Among insurance agents, 36% said they always send AI-generated content to clients without making changes first. The findings also showed that 46% usually or always send unedited AI material while saying they are not very confident their use of the technology is compliant.

The data points to routine use of AI in day-to-day customer communication. Some 62% of property and casualty agents said they use AI tools daily, while 67% said drafting client communications is the main use case.

Other common uses were marketing and social content at 66%, data entry and customer relationship management updates at 64%, and lead follow-up and scheduling at 62%.

The research suggested agents often rely on public AI tools ahead of internal support. When they have a question about using AI at work, 86% said they turn to tools such as ChatGPT, compared with 71% who seek official training or support from their organisation.

Only 27% said they are very likely to use AI tools provided by their organisation rather than ones they find themselves. That was the lowest level among the three industries covered in the study.

Training gaps

Formal training appears to be widespread, but many respondents described it as too broad. While 98% of insurance agents said their organisation had provided formal AI training, 58% said it was broad or general, compared with 40% who received role-specific instruction.

A large majority, 94%, said they see training as a box-checking exercise and prefer to learn on the job. Asked what would be most valuable now, 63% chose AI skills and workflows, ahead of technology and tools at 46% and brand guidelines at 40%.

The appetite for more practical instruction came with wider concerns about support and career prospects. Some 85% agreed that companies do not care about helping independent contractors like them develop AI skills, while 86% said they believe they will probably need to switch careers at some point because of AI.

Brand pressure

The survey also highlighted tension between central brand rules and local sales pressures. Some 82% of insurance agents said they or someone else at their organisation had bent or skipped brand guidelines to close a deal, and 45% said they had done so themselves.

Another 83% said they had lost a client or deal because they lacked local market guidance or materials from the organisation they sell for. Only half strongly agreed that the organisation they represent understands the difference between national brand standards and local market needs.

Just 43% said their organisation offers extensive localised training. More than half, 52%, said clearer brand guidelines would most improve their ability to build business, making insurance agents more likely than agents in the other sectors surveyed to ask for that change.

Loyalty questions

The research linked training quality with retention. Some 76% said that if training takes too long, they are less likely to stay with the organisation they sell for, and 14% said they are very likely to stop selling for their current organisation within the next 12 months.

When asked what would most increase loyalty, 61% chose better AI tools and guidance. That ranked ahead of a better commission or compensation structure at 51%, more support from leadership at 48%, and a clearer career growth path at 45%.

Respondents also indicated a preference for mixed learning formats rather than a single method. Peer discussion forums ranked highest at 52%, followed by live lectures or presentations at 47%, on-demand videos and interactive videos at 42% each, and one-to-one coaching at 41%.

The wider survey compared insurance agents with real estate agents and financial advisers. Insurance agents were more likely than those groups to send unedited AI content to clients, with 74% doing so, against 57% in real estate and 41% in financial advice.

John Mazur, Chief Executive Officer, CYPHER Learning, said the findings showed a mismatch between growing AI use and the guidance available to frontline agents. "For an insurance agent, a copy-and-paste AI message to a policyholder isn't just a typo risk, it's a compliance risk," Mazur said.

"Agents are using AI every day because it helps them serve customers faster, and that's not going to change. What has to change is the guidance behind it. Carriers and agencies need to give agents trusted answers grounded in their own compliance rules and state requirements, a safe way to practice client conversations, and updates that reach every agent the day a rule changes, not weeks later," he said.